
Press release: Unpacking the Just Transition in practice
Article:TIPS says broader, engaged development approaches needed to realise just transition projects (Marleny Arnoldi, Engineering News 25 March 2022)
Background
Development institutions tend to work according to an established framework, which helps practitioners and funders structure and plan their actions. This traditional model is based on empirical observations and on the ground experience of how project development and support policy work in practice. Key steps include:
The above cycle describes an idealised process, which differs from "real-life" processes. Steps are sometimes taken in parallel, and within one cycle not all steps may be covered completely. Recent examination of just transition projects and project development cycles suggest that the characteristics of such projects and their development may require an expanded or amended toolbox of actions, funding and sequencing.
For example, just transition projects require expanded participatory processes. Activities to support meaningful participation may thus need to be undertaken and funded to ensure participating workers or communities are able to engage both at a substantive as well as a process level. Another example is that environmental and green solutions sought by just transition project developers may require the inclusion of an expanded view of beneficiaries, given that environmental systems (such as water sheds) do not adhere to political or community boundaries. A final example is that just transition project developers will most likely require a range of funders to become involved in the project development cycle earlier than in traditional project finance. This idea of financial sector players making deals as opposed to buying deals will require additions to the existing project development and policy support toolbox.
The webinar investigates how different countries deal with these emerging issues. In particular, the following questions will be addressed: Does participatory planning call for different policy instruments and mechanisms as well as a different policy cycle? Do just transition projects require different financial support mechanisms and instruments at different times to traditional projects? How is the scope of just transition projects (especially those seeking to address environmental degradation) different from traditional projects and what instruments, mechanisms and policy support measures can be developed.
Outline of the event
Date: 24 March
Organisations: Trade & Industrial Policy Strategies (TIPS) and Wuppertal Institute für Climate, Environment and Energy (WI)

Enquiries: rozale@tips.org.za
SME Green Economy I-Go Initiative Project (Mbali Moroe: Project Manager, National Cleaner Production Centre of South Africa)
Green Economy Tracker
Online at Green Economy Tracker:
Media
Press release: Is South Africa on track in terms of its Green Economy Recovery objectives
Article: South Africa has strong green economy policies, but implementation a challenge (Marleny Arnoldi, Engineering News 17 February 2021)

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="/
" title="YouTube video player" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen></iframe>Overview
This webinar, organised in partnership with Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies (TIPS), will provide participants with a first look at findings from the International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD) report South Africa's Energy Fiscal Policies: An inventory of subsidies, taxes and policies impacting the energy transition, presenting key takeaways and recommendations.
The report explores the extent to which South Africa's current energy fiscal policies are aligned with its goal to develop a robust domestic energy system that can provide low-carbon energy at a fair cost to all. It provides clear recommendations for the government to align its fiscal energy policies with its climate and energy objectives.
Through a panel discussion and a Q&A session, participants will be encouraged to engage in a debate on carbon tax, bailouts, and what international moves to phase out fossil fuel financing and oil and gas exploration mean for South Africa.
Key questions
AGENDA
| 11:00 | Welcome from the moderator Richard Bridle, Senior Policy Advisor, IISD |
| 11:05 | Opening remarks Sharlin Hemraj, Director: Environment and Fuel Taxes, National Treasury |
| 11:15 | Launching USD report "South Africa's Energy Fiscal Policies" Chido Muzondo, Policy Advisor, IISD |
| 11:25 | Panel discussion • Gaylor Montmasson-Clair, Senior Economist: Sustainable Growth, Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies • Jessie Burton, Senior Associate, E3G (Third Generation Environmentalism) |
| 12:25 | Q&A |
| 13:00 | Close |
Registration
Register online: https://us06web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_5yhGna3LQYicnioMFvzAHg
Presentation: Financial Stakeholder Communication, Awareness and Outreach - (Nicole Martens, Martens Impact Advisory)
Research Report: TIPS Just Transition Finance Roadmap Workstream: Communication, Awareness & Outreach - (Nicole Martens, Martens Impact Advisory)
Presentation: Insights for South africa's Just transition Finance Roadmap: Nexus of Project Needs and Financing Response - (Chantal Naidoo, Rabia Transitions Initiative)
Research Report: Insights for South Africa's Just transition Finance Roadmap: Nexus of Project Needs and Financing Response - (Chantal Naidoo, Rabia Transitions Initiative)
Presentation: Scaling Community JT Projects Towards a Just Transition (Fumani Mthembi, Knowledge Pele)
Research Report: Scaling the Just Transition for Community-based and Community-placed projects - Fumani Mthembi (Knowledge Pele)
Media
Press release: Financing the Just Transition puts a spotlight on financial institutions
Article: Ramaphosa to chair inter-Ministerial committee to oversee R131bn just transition offer (Terence Creamer, Engineering News 25 November 2021)
Article: Just Transition: SA's battle for green power accreditation (Thuletho Zwane, City Press 28 November 2021)
Background
The roadmap towards financing a just transition seeks to make explicit the link between actions in the financial system and the realisation of broader national goals of sustainability and socio-economic development. The country’s roadmap will be a function of its national context and climate action ambitions, and aims to develop a long-term systemic plan to enhance the ability of the financial ecosystem to mainstream environmental, social, governance (ESG) factors; sustainable development goals (SDGs); and just transition goals into decision-making and capital allocation. In South Africa, an additional fundamental aim of the roadmap will be to mobilise offshore public sector funding and private local capital for such investment, given the limited fiscal space.
This seminar will discuss the bottom-up approach used in the research process, what could work within the current financial system, and where changes to the financial ecosystem are needed to effectively support a just transition. Research commissioned by TIPS will be presented on topics that help to unpack the finance roadmap and provide insights on scale and replicability of projects, financial instruments, social indicators, and corporate awareness, outreach and communication.
Presentations
Ulrich Harmes-Liedtke - Partner at Mesopartner
Presentation: Global trends in Quality Infrastructure
Eduardo Trajano Gadret - Researcher-Technologist in Metrology and Qualith at INMENTO
Presentation: Quality Infrastructure in Brazil
Martin Chesire - Chief Executive Officer at Kenya Accreditation Service (KENAS)
Presentation: Quality Infrastructure in Kenya
Programme
14:00: Facilitator opens the seminar: Saul Levin
14:05: Opening remarks Tshenge Demana: Quality Infrastructure in support of industrial development
14:10-14:20 Global trends in Quality Infrastructure: Ulrich Harmes-Liedtke
14:20-14:45 Presentations on international experience in Quality Infrastructure institutional role:
14:45-15:15 Discussion and engagement on how experiences of QI development could enrich South Africa in the context of Post-COVID-19 economic recovery
15:15 Closure
Background
South Africa’s industrial policy aims to bring about a change in the structure of the economy to put the economy on a more inclusive, industrialised and sustainable path. Quality Infrastructure (QI) institutions (SABS, NMISA, NRCS, and SANAS) are part and parcel of industrial policy measures, with international experience seeing a correlation between levels of economic development and robustness or effectiveness of a country’s QI. With the QI system evolving globally and an improved understanding of its critical role in industrial policy, consideration needs to be given to its role in post-COVID-19 economic recovery plans.
Zoom meeting details
Register online